Journal of Dentomaxillofacial- Reviewers Section
referees page

Clear images and colors

  In The Name of God

  Journal of Dentomaxillofacial Radiology, Pathology and Surgery

  Reviewer Recommendation and Suggestions

  Manuscript Title:

  Manuscript Number:

  Reviewer (1, 2, 3):

  Please give the score from 1 to 5 (1=poor and 5=excellent) into the provided boxes:

  -Novelty of the manuscript 1   2   3   4   5

  -Significance of the submitted paper to the field of Dentistry  1   2   3   4   5

  -Association and relevancy to the field of journal  1   2  3   4   5

  -Proper English structure  1   2   3   4   5

  - No Repetition of previous research  1   2   3   4   5

  We suggest you copy and paste your comments into the provided section:

  -Confidential suggestion to editor (provide a recommendation about the manuscripts suitability for publication in the journal and other necessary suggestions)

  -Reviewer suggestion to author(s):

  *Title:

  *Abstract:

  *Introduction:

  *Materials and Methods:

  *Results:

  *Figures:

  *Tables

  *Discussion and conclusion:

  *Reference:

  *Overall suggestion:

  Please provide answers to below specific questions:

  Title

  Is the title clear and concise? Yes    No  

  Abstract:

  Is the abstract satisfactory? Yes  No  

  Does it concern the purpose of the work and what was done and? Yes  No 

  Text

  Is the study design scientifically valid? Yes  No 

  Have all abbreviations been explained in the text? Yes  No 

  Were the methods sufficiently Novel? Yes  No  

  Were the findings sufficiently Novel? Yes  No  

  Do the results present the data properly? Yes   No  

  Does the discussion explain and discuss the results of the study? Yes   No  

  Is the conclusion satisfactory? Yes  No  

  Does the conclusion support the data? Yes  No 

  Is the length of paper appropriate? Yes  No 

  Was the text well-written? Yes  No 

  Reference

  Do the references follow the guidelines? Yes  No 

  Tables

  Are all the tables necessary? Yes  No 

  Can they be simplified or condensed? Yes  No 

  Dose the layout of the table has proper design? Yes  No 

  Is the data arranged properly? Yes  No 

  Is the legend of each table satisfactory? Yes  No 

  Figures:

  Are the number and quality of figures satisfactory? Yes  No 

  Do the legends explain the figures properly? Yes  No 

  Statistics:

  

  Is the correct statistical test used for data analysis? Yes  No 

  Ethical Concerns:

  Are there any ethical considerations? Yes  No 

  Were the studies performed in accordance whit the declaration of Helsinki? Yes   No 

  Recommendation:

  Accepted   

  Accepted with minor revision  

  Major revision required    

  Rejected   

Topic URL in Journal of Dentomaxillofacial website:
http://3dj.gums.ac.ir/find.php?item=1.24.22.en
Back to content primary page